data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/943ca/943ca34099d6c10c0aabf8f5c067af1208cd6481" alt=""
What was immediately obvious about this opening First National film was its quality. The sets, costume and story are all far superior
to pretty much anything seen in a Chaplin film before. The sets especially look
as though they may well have been real streets. There is a much more rounded
story which incorporates comedy as one aspect rather than relying solely on
kicks up the backside or doffing caps to curbs. The film is still funny but
this isn’t one of Chaplin’s finest works. What it is though is one of his
finest stories to date and overall one of his best short films.