After the wonderful highs of The Bank, this film was a huge come down. It is by far my least
favourite Charlie Chaplin film to date although there are inevitably some good
moments to be found.
The only joke that made me laugh out loud was Chaplin’s
ridiculous naval salute which was somewhere between blowing a raspberry and a
high five. While that is hilarious, the rest of the film isn’t. The only other
joke that made me even smile was when Chaplin throws a rescue rope behind him
by accident. The rest of the gags were mediocre. Chaplin was to find success
with a nautical theme just a couple of years later in The Immigrant and you can see the workings of some of the jokes
from that classic film during Shanghaied.
The most notable of these was the dinner during choppy seas. In addition to
one or two decent jokes there is also some nice close-up work, something which
was rare for Chaplin at the time. In one scene the fuse of some dynamite is
shown in very close zoom rather than the traditional wide shot of the whole
set. This marks further development of Chaplin’s ever expanding film craft. The
one final aspect of the film that I enjoyed was Chaplin’s incredible tray
handling skills. This is something he revisited years later in Modern Times but
while it is more spectacular there, it feels much more real here.
As well as The Immigrant
the film also has shades of Buster Keaton’s Steamboat Bill Jr in that both central characters are bumbling buffoons
in love with a ship owner’s daughter. Keaton’s later film undoubtedly takes
some elements from Shanghaied but
adds much more and is a far superior film. Keaton's film actually contains a subtle nod to Chaplin during a scene in which Keaton is trying on hats.
The cast features Chaplin's regular troupe of actors, most of which over act under heavy false beards and eyebrows and includes the likes of Bud Jamison, Leo White, Billy Armstrong, Paddy McGuire and Wesley Ruggles. These are actors which Chaplin knew well by now with most appearing in all of his films.
My main problems with this film were that the story felt
under developed and there weren’t enough jokes. It feels like Chaplin got an
idea of ‘the Tramp on a ship’ and just made it up as he went along (something
that was often the case in early Chaplin films). While this was sometimes very successful,
here it is far less so.
4/10
I agree with your assessment. There was one rather shabby part when to simulate the boat moving they simply wobbled the camera about but since the shot was out on deck you could see the horizon wobble with it so it defeated the purpose of the action. However, I found the physicality of Chaplin in this one quite impressive, the way in which he falls down into the hold and bounces around the ship as its moving. He catches a plate flipped up by the captain whilst the floor is tipping around deftly and serves food on it. He plays around with what looks like a leg of meat twirling it like a baton and bouncing it off his leg expertly. Its not surprising some people describe him as a ballet dancer.
ReplyDeleteYeah, Chaplin's physicality could easy be compared to ballet. He moves with a lot of grace and poise.
Delete