Patrick (Bradley Cooper), recently diagnosed with bi-polar
is released from a psychiatric hospital eight months after nearly beating a man
to death for sleeping with his wife. He arrives home to find that his superstitious
father (Robert De Niro) has lost his job and is making money as a bookmaker on
American Football games. Patrick is desperate to reconnect with his wife
despite their problems and a restraining order and soon falls in with a friend
of a friend called Tiffany (Jennifer Lawrence) who promises to get a letter to
Patrick’s wife in exchange for help in a dance competition.
I had no interest in seeing Silver Linings Playbook, especially after my girlfriend saw it and
gave a one word review of “meh-umm-yeah”. A friend of mine though said it was
excellent and it’s popping up in awards nominations and best of lists so I thought
I should check it out. If the film gets anywhere near any major awards for
anything other than acting, I will be shocked. The film is average at best but flourishes
due to some great acting performances which start at the leads and extend right
down to the secondary and tertiary characters.
One of the problems I had with the film is that I rarely if
ever cared about the characters. Occasionally I felt sorry for Robert De Niro’s
character but that was as far as my compassion went. Even though Jennifer
Lawrence was playing a widow in his early twenties, the writing gave me no
reason to feel sorry for her or care about how she got on with her dancing.
Additionally someone very close to me is bi-polar so I thought that I’d be touched
by seeing the disorder on screen. In the end the film seems to suggest that
sometimes you’re up, other times you’re down and then you’re better. Although
Cooper was very good, I wasn’t really interested in him or his problems. I was
never able to get on board with anything that was happening. A further problem
I had is that the ending was never in any doubt. There were three things that
were riding on a happy ending; a football match, a dance and a relationship but
I never for one moment felt as though one was in doubt. Because of this I lost
interest and my mind strayed, often to wondering how close Jennifer Lawrence’s
figure is to Marilyn Monroe’s. She has an extremely small middle and squidgy
bits elsewhere, like what men like.
On a technical level the film is fine and the cinematography
is good in places. I enjoyed the jogging scenes and the way Tiffany managed to
sneak up on Pat and there were scenes in a dance studio which I enjoyed. The
camera seemed to dance around the characters as they themselves danced, always
managing to avoid being seen in the large wall length mirror. On one occasion I’m
sure I saw a camera man’s foot but otherwise the sequences were very well done.
The soundtrack was also quite good and avoided the typical mushy nonsense of a
romantic comedy. Led Zeppelin even feature in a pivotal scene. What is and What Should Never Be is a
song I don’t recall hearing during a movie before and was grateful for its
inclusion. It worked really well during the scene and Bob Dylan, The White
Stripes and Eagles of Death Metal also feature in what is a fairly manly
sounding soundtrack.
The highlight of the film though is its acting. It would be
cruel to Jennifer Lawrence to call this the performance of her short career to
date but I think it can be said of Bradley Cooper. I wouldn’t go so far as to
say they are incredible but both are very good. Lawrence has moments of extreme madness and
Cooper’s up and down personality is generally well handled. Both have an
occasional frenetic moment which is where the film is at its best. The
conclusion to their story and various problems felt too fairytale for me
though. Robert De Niro produces his best performance for several years. As much
as I love Bobby D, he has pretty much phoned in his performances for the last
few years so it’s nice to see him really go for it and have something he can
get his teeth into. Jacki Weaver is also good although her Aussie accent
occasionally penetrates her Philly one. Another standout is a toned down Chris
Tucker. He is usually an exasperating screen presence but here is quieter and
more measured. He gives just enough crazy without going overboard.
Overall Silver Linings
Playbook won’t be troubling my best of year list and I have to wonder
whether the acting and subject matter is clouding the views of others. The
depiction is mental illness is far too glossy and ‘Hollywood’ and the film
seems to suggest that problems can be fixed with a dance and a new partner. The
script has its moments but features long periods of dull nothingness and is
saved by some great performances from a strong and talented cast.
6/10
It's a beautiful flick that definitely deserves a bunch of nominations, even if I do feel like it won't get many wins in the long-run. That's fine with me though, I'm just glad it would be considered none the less. Great review Tom.
ReplyDeleteI wouldn't be surprised to see Jennifer Lawrence pick up the odd award.
DeleteI just saw this movie tonight. I thought it was great. I really wanted Pat's mom to tell his father to back off!
ReplyDelete